Dooce, carseats and false and dangerous logic...
On this page a number of people made comments about this photo in which an 11mo child is in a forward facing carseat and commented about carseat regulations in general.
After a little bourbon and a lack of patience, Dooce commented on the carseat posts and what she said made absolute sense. The child was very tall and 11 months old. As with most things, this mirrored my own experience exactly: Kieran was too tall to comfortably fit into his rear-facing seat, so at about 10.5 months, we turned him and his seat around. That in addition to the fact that we couldn't see over the fucking seat half of the time because it's so bloody high!
The regulation, which is slightly different from state to state and province to province, generally states that a child should face rearward in an appropriate carseat until 12 months AND 20lbs.
Here's the part of the whole thing that bothered me. Dooce finished her comment with one of the most disappointing remarks I've ever heard connected to any safety issue regarding children: "i distinctly remember standing up in the backseat of my father’s GTO when I was three-years-old." And while she goes on to say that her father hasn't yet been arrested, the implication is that "I did it and I'm fine".
I can't tell you how many times I've heard this and how much it bothers me.
I, too, am too old to have been taken home from the hospital in a carseat. I never sat in a carseat. Most of the vehicles I rode in as a child didn't even have seat belts! And I'm still here. Unfortunately, there are millions of babies and children who are no longer alive from that era to attest, with me and Dooce and you too, gentle reader, to the relative safety of riding in cars improperly secured. The fact that I survived my childhood's carrides alive and without injury is just lucky and I am thankful for that bit of luck.
I don't think Dooce is evil, I don't think she's stupid or anything degrading at all. I do, however, think she said something irresponsible after having already intelligently defending herself against the extremist hordes and unwittingly contributed power to the purveyers of false and dangerous logic.





